Melodrama
Films are a sub-type of drama films,
characterized by a plot to appeal to the heightened emotions of
the audience. Melodrama, a combination of drama and melos (music),
literally means
"play with music." The themes of dramas, the oldest literary
and stage art form, were exaggerated within melodramas, and the liberal
use of music often enhanced their emotional plots. Often, film studies
criticism used the term 'melodrama' pejoratively to connote an unrealistic,
pathos-filled, campy tale of romance or domestic situations with stereotypical
characters (often including a central female character) that would directly
appeal to feminine audiences. The sub-genre is typically looked down upon
by critics and elitists.
There are many names for melodramatic films - 'women's pictures',
'weepies', tearjerkers, soap operas (or soapers), and more recently, 'chick
flicks'. O Magazine compiled their 50
Greatest Chick Flicks in their July 2004 issue.). See Filmsite's own Memorable
and Great "Chick Flicks."
Pure
melodramas reached their pinnacle in the films of the 50s by director
Douglas Sirk. See also this site's extensive, illustrated compilation: Greatest
Tearjerker Films, Moments and Scenes. (Entertainment
Weekly's November 28, 2003
issue listed their choices for the Top
50 Greatest Tearjerkers: each one "involves a terminally
ill loved one, or an impossible love, or a giant robot that dies
for our sins.") However, not all melodramas are tearjerkers,
but more like heightened dramas.
Melodramatic plots with heart-tugging (literally tear-jerking),
emotional plots (requiring multiple hankies) usually emphasize sensational
situations or crises of human emotion, failed romance or friendship,
strained familial situations, tragedy, illness, loss (the death of
a child or spouse), neuroses, or emotional and physical hardships within
everyday life. Victims, couples, virtuous and heroic characters or
suffering protagonists (usually heroines) in melodramas are presented
with tremendous social pressures, threats, repression, fears, improbable
events or difficulties with friends, community, work, lovers, or family.
The melodramatic format allows the character(s) to work through their
difficulties or surmount the problems with resolute endurance, sacrificial
acts, and steadfast bravery.
Melodramas were the prime form of dramas until they were overtaken
by straight-forward, realistic dramatic forms in the 50s and afterwards, although
they continue to occasionally appear into the present. Even today, horror
films, adventure pictures, war movies, thriller films, and even westerns (such
as Fred Zinnemann's psychological western High Noon (1952) and Delmer Daves' 3:10 to Yuma (1957)) are
described as melodramatic.
Directors that have often been associated with melodramas
include the following:
Frank
Borzage - his definitive works being Man's Castle (1933), The
Mortal Storm (1940), and Moonrise (1948); also Borzage's romantic
melodramas including: Seventh Heaven (1927) and Street Angel (1928) - both with Charles Farrell and Janet Gaynor
- George Cukor - a legendary 'women's director'; noted for The Women (1939) - a melodramatic comedy based on the hit play by Clare Boothe Luce with an all-female cast
(Norma Shearer, Joan Crawford, Rosalind Russell, Mary Boland, Paulette Goddard, and Joan Fontaine, among others) - a group of catty, back-biting, competitive, and richly-spoiled high-society
women, although its tagline tauts: "It's All About Men!"; while seeking divorces in Reno, women learn of other affairs and infidelities and are forced to make tough decisions
- Max Ophuls - known for his German film Liebelei
(1933, Germany) about a tragic love, the melodramatic noir Caught
(1949), and for the quintessential Letter
From an Unknown Woman (1948) - a classic tale of unrequited
love
- Douglas Sirk - with 50's classics including All That
Heaven Allows (1955), Written on the Wind (1956),
and Imitation of Life (1959)
- Vincente Minnelli - examples include The
Bad and the Beautiful (1952), the slow-burning character
study Some
Came Running (1958) with Frank Sinatra in the lead role as a
returning soldier to a Midwestern Indiana town, and the soapy romantic
drama The
Sandpiper (1965) starring Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton
Early Melodramas:
Tragically-realistic
films were a big part of the silent film era - the silents naturally lent
themselves to melodrama. The only means by which an actor or actress could
communicate meaning and feelings was through facial expressions and gestures.
One of the earliest melodramas was director Frank Powell's silent film (based
upon a stage play) titled A Fool There Was (1915), with Theda Bara
(in her star-making film debut) cast as an evil, dark, wicked and mysterious
vampire who seductively lures a weak-willed family man away and controls his
heart with her sexy wiles.
The
master of silent melodramas was director D. W. Griffith, who featured the
innocent heroine Lillian Gish in many of his films, such as True Heart
Susie (1919), with Gish as a long-suffering plain country girl who painfully
sacrifices herself for her neighbor boy-lover - who eventually marries someone
else. In Broken Blossoms (1919), she portrayed a fragile and waif-like daughter
of an abusive prizefighter. Further Griffith films included the melodramatic
epic of the French Revolution Orphans of the Storm (1922) and of World
War I Hearts of the World (1918). In Way Down
East (1920) Gish starred as a naive and wronged woman after being
seduced, made pregnant, and abandoned. Small-town prejudice sends Gish into
a death-threatening blizzard and entrapment on an ice floe. King Vidor's WWI
epic The Big Parade (1925) featured melodrama within the romantic subplot
between a French girl (Renee Adoree) and an American doughboy (John Gilbert).
One of the earliest, most influential romantic melodramas of the era was the
classic silent masterpiece from F. W. Murnau titled Sunrise (1927). Another was director Erich von Stroheim's silent
masterpiece Greed (1924) - a marital drama about an avaricious couple.
Fannie Hurst's best-selling, tear-jerking novel of an ill-fated
romance and sacrificial love was remade numerous times: John Stahl's Back
Street (1932) with Irene Dunne and John Boles, Robert Stevenson's Back
Street (1941) with Charles Boyer and Margaret Sullavan, and David Miller's Back Street (1961) with Susan Hayward and John Gavin.
Melodramatic Tales of Fallen and Liberated Women:
Before the Production Code Administration in 1934 clamped
down with strict censorship codes, Hollywood produced a number of frank and
sordid melodramas featuring tough, sinful, bawdy, naughty and fallen women,
pleasure-loving golddiggers, prostitutes and ruthless divorcees - some of
whom were repaid for their sinfulness and indiscretions by rejection, drug-addiction,
death, or anonymity. The silent Madame X (1920) was one of the first
of such films - in which a woman (Pauline Frederick) was separated from her
legitimate child, and then defended by her unknowing, grown-up son when wrongly
accused of murder.
Norma
Shearer won the Best Actress Oscar for MGM's The Divorcee (1930) as
a recent divorcee who finds revenge on her faithless husband by becoming a
philanderer herself. Cecil B. DeMille directed the outrageous Madam Satan
(1930) about a wealthy socialite (Kay Johnson) who pretends to be a sultry
French vamp in order to seduce her own husband away from his mistress. (The
film featured an infamous debauchery scene - a masquerade costume ball aboard
a zeppelin dirigible above New York harbor.)
Gloria
Swanson (in Manhandled (1924), and in Sadie Thompson (1928) as a fallen woman of loose morals), and liberated sexy screen siren Clara
Bow (in My Lady of Whims (1925), Mantrap (1926), Dancing
Mothers (1926), the star-making light comedy It (1927) ("It"
means sex appeal), and Hula (1928)) emerged as the newest stars of
melodramatic pictures in the 20s. Liberated females (society women, stenographers,
actress/starlets) were the main characters in pre-code melodramatic soap operas,
including MGM's pre-censorship era Three On A Match (1932) featuring
three girlhood friends - a working girl stenographer (Bette Davis), a bored
society dame and rich man's wife (Ann Dvorak) and a jaded showgirl/actress
with a gangster boyfriend (Joan Blondell), and What Price Hollywood? (1932) with Constance Bennett as an aspiring young Hollywood starlet (later remade
three times as A Star is Born in 1937 (with Janet Gaynor), 1954 (with
Judy Garland), and 1976).
One of the only female Hollywood directors in the 1930s
was Dorothy Arzner, who made Katharine Hepburn's second film, giving
the actress her first starring role in Christopher Strong (1933),
a tale of a daring female aviator who fell in love with a married
British statesman. Margaret Sullavan starred in her first role as
an unwed mother (with an unknowing father) in Only Yesterday (1933).
In Chinese cinema, one of the best "fallen woman" melodramas
was director
Wu Yonggang's (his debut film) silent melodrama The Goddess
(1934, China) (aka Shen nu), about social injustice
and maternal sacrifice - a tragic tale about the hard-times of a 1930s
Shanghai, China prostitute (a "fallen woman") known only
as 'The Goddess' (Ruan Ling-Yu). The single mother-streetwalker was
raising her son in the hellish and foul city (in the midst of a civil
war). [Note: Stanley Kwan's biopic Center
Stage (1991, HK) (aka The Actress, or Ruan Lingyu) was the life
story of Ruan Ling-Yu, portrayed by Maggie Cheung.]
By
1934, explicit tales of fallen women involved in dangerous or disastrous
relationships with men came to be banned or rigorously censored by
the Production Code censors.
The 30s "Weepies":
Hollywood
cranked out women's pictures (or 'weepies' as they came to be known,
or are now known as "chick flicks")
with excessive emotional fervor in the 1930s and after. In part because they
contained few strong male characters and matinee idols suitable for swooning,
they were films created for the female segment of the audience. Producers
thought women would be more interested than men in relationships, love, and
marriage, thereby escaping from their own problems, and empathizing (and weeping)
with the on-screen sufferings of strong female protagonists. Female audiences
would be attracted to plot lines that included doomed love affairs, infidelity,
unrequited love, various family crises, or marital separation. The protagonists
of women's films would often overcome stereotypical gender roles, and the
films would examine the strong achievements of these characters.
Five female actresses were known for their redefinition of
feminine roles in the 1930s (both pre- and post- code):
-
BARBARA
STANWYCK: appearing as a shrewd, tough-minded, often amoral and wisecracking
woman, in Frank Capra's Ladies of Leisure (1930) as a gold-digger,
in William Wellman's sordid pre-code Night Nurse (1931) with several
scenes of undressing, in the hit Illicit (1931) as a free-spirited,
co-habitating adventuress, in Frank Capra's Forbidden (1932) as a
liberated heroine, in Shopworn (1932), in Warner Bros.' prison
drama Ladies They Talk About (1933) as a tough-talking, imprisoned
gangster's moll, in the risque Baby Face (1933) as a street-wise
dame who uses men to climb to the top of the corporate ladder, and in Warner
Bros.' Gambling Lady (1934) - films now marketed as "Forbidden
Hollywood"
- MARLENE DIETRICH: often appearing as an exotically-perverse,
sensual, sometimes androgynous, and seductive character, as a cabaret singer
in The Blue Angel (1930), Morocco (1930) and Blonde Venus
(1932), as an alluring woman in the historical melodrama The Devil
is a Woman (1935), and as an exotic South Seas vamp/entertainer in Seven
Sinners (1940)
GRETA
GARBO: bewitching, enigmatic, often tragic and desirable, in Anna
Christie (1930) as an ex-prostitute, in Mata Hari (1931) as the infamous exotic WWI dancer/spy ultimately destroyed by her love of
a young Russian, in Susan Lenox: Her Fall and Rise (1931) as an on-the-run
fallen woman, in the historical costume drama Queen
Christina (1933) as a self-exiled Swedish queen, in Anna Karenina
(1935), and as a dying courtesan in the suffering romantic love film Camille (1936)
- JOAN CRAWFORD: glamorous and often fashionable,
as a decadent flapper hurt by the Stock Market Crash in Dance,
Fools, Dance (1931), as a struggling wronged prostitute in Rain
(1932),
in the vintage melodrama Sadie McKee (1934) as the sexy title
character, in the historical costume drama The Gorgeous Hussy (1936) as
Peggy O'Neal Eaton - Andrew Jackson's mistress, in the romantic dramas The
Bride Wore Red (1937) and director Frank Borzage's Mannequin
(1937),
in Borzage's doomed romance The Shining Hour (1938) and in the
mystical melodrama Strange Cargo (1940) as a trollop teamed
with Clark Gable, and in A Woman's Face (1941) as a sullen,
scar-faced blackmailing con. MGM's Grand Hotel
(1932)
starred both a financially-struggling, on the make stenographer Crawford
and a tragically-radiant Garbo with Berlin's Grand Hotel as the backdrop
for its anthology (portmanteau film) of intersecting lives of different
characters.
JEAN
HARLOW: a platinum blonde sexpot appearing as a smart-aleck vamp in
pre-Hays Code productions, in films such as in Howard Hughes' WWI war drama Hell's Angels (1930) - the film with her
famous question: "Would you be shocked if I changed into something
more comfortable?", the steamy classic Red Dust
(1932) where she played a stranded prostitute on an Indochinese
rubber plantation run by loutish Clark Gable, as an indiscreet, trashy home-wrecking
gold-digger (with her blonde hair dyed red) in Red Headed Woman (1932),
as a Broadway song and dance showgirl in Reckless (1935), as a tough,
questionable woman who ends up pregnant in a reform school in Hold Your
Man (1933), and as a working girl who is again pregnant and jailed in Riffraff (1935).
Maternal Melodramas: Definitive Examples
Maternal melodramas featured plots with sacrificial, selfless
mother-loving figures who suffered hardships. They were a popular tearjerker
(or 'soaper') sub-genre requiring multiple hankies to make it to the emotional
finales. Maternal characters were cruelly neglected and scorned by their children,
or separated from their children for any number of causes (social pressures
to give up the child, financial destitution, scandal or a moral lapse, etc.).
However victimized, they would often become heroines by sacrificing themselves
for their children.
Many
exceptional films are noted for being definitive, mother-love 'weepies':
- Best Actress Oscar-winning Helen Hayes (in her first film
role) as a devoted, all-suffering heroine toward her child born out of wedlock
(Robert Taylor), by becoming a street-walker in the early The Sin of
Madelon Claudet (1931)
- the emotional telling of Fannie Hurst's story of a widowed
mother (Claudette Colbert, Lana Turner) and a black maid (Louise Beavers,
Juanita Moore) who both have problems with their love-starved and troubled
daughters (Rochelle Hudson, Fredi Washington; Sandra Dee, Susan Kohner)
- one of whom is light-skinned, in John Stahl's restrained Imitation
of Life (1934) and Douglas Sirk's glamorized, ultra-emotional
version Imitation of Life (1959)
- King Vidor's Stella Dallas (1937) with a self-sacrificing,
adoring, poverty-stricken mother Stella (Barbara Stanwyck) giving all for
her daughter Laurel (Anne Shirley) in the film's heart-breaking finale in
the rain; also director Henry King's popular silent soaper Stella Dallas
(1925) starred Belle Bennett
Edmund
Goulding's soap opera That Certain Woman (1937) with Bette Davis
as a sacrificial wife and mother after an annulled marriage to Henry Fonda
(this was a remake of the silent film The Trespasser (1929), starring
Gloria Swanson - in her first talkie)
- another collaboration between Bette Davis and Edmund Goulding
- with Davis as an embittered, long-suffering 'old maid' spinster - and
unwed mother who gives up her illegitimate daughter to be raised by her
selfish, married and childless cousin (Miriam Hopkins) in the superb The
Old Maid (1939)
- in Edmund Goulding's The Great Lie (1941), newly-widowed
Bette Davis aids her husband's pregnant ex-wife (Mary Astor) in bearing
and then raising the child
- Best Actress Oscar-winning Olivia de Haviland as a loving
mother who selflessly gives up her illegitimate son (conceived with a WWI
fighter pilot who dies in battle before they can marry) for adoption and
then becomes her son's 'aunt' without revealing the truth in To Each
His Own (1946)
- the melodramatic film-noir classic Mildred
Pierce (1945) starred Best Actress Oscar-winner Joan Crawford (who
took the role that had been rejected by both Davis and Stanwyck) as a hard-working,
excessively-devoted, long-suffering divorcee/mother for her spoiled, murderous
daughter Veda (Ann Blyth)
|