Understanding the Selections
for Greatest Films:
Commentary
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/34017/34017808bddf06c1614bb1313fd7b33c9ed4787c" alt=""
All film criticism is extremely subjective and there is no such
thing as the definitive list of the 100 Greatest (English-language)
Films. Great Films can't be measured scientifically because
greatness is extremely subjective. The artistic greatness of films
(and other works of art) can never be rated or quantified, although
critics, reviewers, and fans persistently make ten best lists,
hundred best lists, all-time greatest lists, awards lists, and
generate results of polls. There is no accepted standard for rating
cinematic works - there are 4-star and 5-star scales, 1-10 and
percentage ratings, letter grades, fresh/rotten tomatoes meters,
and thumbs up/down judgments, to name a few. These only confuse
the issue. This site steadfastly refuses to rank films, since
it is completely frivolous to say one great film is a notch higher
than another one.
In
a sense, anyone who watches a film is instantly a film critic.
Therefore, everyone will have their own favorites, choices, or
other criteria for selection of the greatest films, and some may
disagree with at least some of the selections below. This selection
of 100 Greatest Films in the last century of film-making
covers, by conscious choice, a wide range of genres, decades,
stars and directors. Emphasis in these selections is purposely
directed toward earlier, more classic Hollywood/American films
than more recent films, although some recent films (and British
films) are included. (An Additional
100 Greatest Films, and Third
100 Greatest Films, and a compiled, chronological listing
of all 200 and 300
Greatest Films are also indexed here.) The Greatest Films
selected do not include foreign films or non-English language
films for purposes of specialization and focus. Negative judgment
on foreign films or non-English language films is not intended
or implied. (See Movieline's 100
Greatest Foreign Films provided at this site.)
Over a long period of time, the English-language
films found here have repeatedly appeared on all-time best film
lists and are often noted in the collective responses of film
viewers and critics. See this site's Summary
of the Top Films of All-Time - an attempt to compile various
rankings of films together in one place and provide comparisons
of film rankings over time. Arguably, there has been reasonable
consensus by most film historians, critics, movie-lovers, and
reviewers that the selections chosen by this site are among cinema's
most critically-acclaimed, significant "must-see" films (of predominantly
Hollywood-American production). They are the films almost every
educated person with a solid knowledge of film history and cinema
would be expected to know and be literate about. See also this
site's Tips on Viewing Films Critically.
These
crucial film selections provide a common ground and foundation
for the study of film. They have undoubtedly left an indelible
mark upon our lives and reflect many defining moments of the last
100 years. They are films that give us pieces of time that we
can never forget. They have refused to fade from memory even after
the long passage of time - they share the unifying fact of being
seen and talked about decades after they were made. Many of these
Greatest Films were made decades ago, and overlooked when
they were first released, yet they have endured the test of time.
They have the power to entertain, enchant, inform, and move us
emotionally - and change our perceptions of things. There is nothing
more dissimilar than a selection of great films - just naturally,
there will be comedies, dramas, westerns, animations, silent films,
etc., that are impossible to rank or quantify against each other
in a collection of masterpieces. The films below range from the
earliest defining silent films of Hollywood, to all the genre
types (screwball comedies, westerns, etc.), and to the blockbusters
and epics of today.
Comparative
analysis and criticism provide the rationale for having many
Other
Greatest Film Lists posted, including other listings
such as AFI's 100
Greatest American Films.
|